![Alice B. Toklas and Gertrude Stein from their literary archive at Beinecke Library](/wp-content/uploads/basketpepe_0-349x349.jpeg)
Name
Gertrude Stein
Birth
February 3, 1874, Allegheny, Pennsylvania
Death
July 27, 1946, Neuilly-sur-Seine, France
Country of Origin/Citizenship
United States/American
Kind of Artist/Cultural Worker
writer, poet, art collector
Avant-Garde Movements Associated With
Cubism, Modernism, Feminism
Date & Places of Overlap with Loy
Paris: 1910 - 1938, 27 rue de Fleurus
Born in Allegheny, Pennsylvania, Gertrude Stein is one of the most prominent figures in American literature. She developed a taste for European culture at the age of three when her family moved to Vienna and Paris for a year, and spent her adult life living in Paris (Sprigge). From 1893 to 1897, Stein participated in psychological research at Radcliffe College studying under William James. Steinâs work reflects the âsteam of consciousnessâ technique he theorized  and taught (Greenfield). Having studied art and medicine in America, in 1902 Stein accompanied her brother, Leo, to London and then Paris (Galvin). Upon moving to France, they became known for hosting avant-garde artists and writers in their Paris salon.
Stein and her brother shared living quarters in a two-story apartment (with adjacent studio) located on the interior courtyard at 27 rue de Fluers. Here they accumulated and housed works of art from the likes of Matisse, Picasso, CĂ©zanne, and Renoir. By 1906 they had a collection of avant-garde art that is renowned for its foresight and historical importance. From 1903 to 1938 many talented artists and writers, who Stein dubbed the âLost Generation,â gathered at the salon, viewing the art and engaging in conversation (Greenfield). It was during this time that Stein began submitting writings of her college experiences for publication. Her first published book, Three Lives, released in 1909, sold poorly. Among Steinâs most famous works are The Making of Americans (written 1906â8, published 1925), Tender Buttons (1914), and The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas (1933), a book written from the point of view of Toklas but telling the story of Steinâs life. Although Stein books did not sell well in America, she eventually developed a level of celebrity. Hers was a legacy built largely and enthusiastically by her friend, Mabel Dodge. In her article, âSpeculations, or Post-Impressions in Prose,â Dodge declares Stein âis doing with words what Picasso is doing with paintâ (Burke 146). A sentiment that bled into American culture over the next twenty years.
Known for her experimental literary style, which is often paralleled to Picassoâs Cubism, her employment of visual forms and experimental writing arguably make her the most prominent and radical of all the modernists (Loy). Her forward-thinking composition, âPatriarchal Poetryâ (1953) categorically deconstructs language. Stein incorporates witty, and strategically staged repetition, variation, and rhyme in order to breaking away from traditional poetics (Nelson 22). Her often rhythmical and cadenced writing leaves readers wondering just what are the poetic parameters? By exposing gendered and hierarchical biases, Stein collapses adopted meanings and presents language that can âfunction as neutral syntactic unitsâ freeing the reader to ârecognize patterns of semantic association that all language carries with its useâ (22). Incorporating everyday thought and imagery, Stein disrupts the metaphoric logic that defines society, challenging both reader and culture to reevaluate what has been assumed (22).
As with a piece of art, Steinâs writing forces the reader to stop, view, and process language outside of appropriated conceptual meanings. Creating poetics and prose that can be seen, heard, and internalized. An admirer of her work, noted critic and photographer, Carl Van Vechten brought Stein âfrom obscurity and into the mainstreamâ (White). After meeting Stein in 1913, his interest in Stein âswiftly morphed into an obsessionâ (White). The two became lifelong friends and champions of each otherâs work, although Stein was tentative in her praises. He promoted her work by acting as Steinâs American agent. He went so far as to write an article in the popular arts magazine, The Trend entitled, âHow to Read Gertrude Steinâ (1914), as an insiderâs guide to understanding Steinâs work and her personality (White). The two were so close that they devised pet names for each other: âPapa Woojumsâ for Van Vechten, Mama Woojums for Toklas, and âBaby Woojumsâ for Stein (White).
Another close friend was Mina Loy. Introduced in 1910 through Mabel Dodge, they remained life-long friends (Burke 119). Stein comments that Loy showed interest and had âalways been able to understandâ her writing (130). Likewise, Loy credits Stein with opening her up to a ânew form of expressionâ that âturn[ed] her sights toward the New World and inspire[d] her to writeâ (119). Both explored the relationship between human consciousness and literary and artistic expression in their writing, elevating and internalizing the literary experience (Goody). Something not always appreciated by critics and audiences. After the publication of The Making of Americans there were so few positive responses that Stein notes, âI am writing for myself and strangersâ (Burke 130). Stephen Haweis, Loyâs first husband pleaded with Stein to insert commas into her long, unpunctuated sentences. Stein replied that âcommas were unnecessary, the sense should be intrinsic and not have to be explained by commasâ (Burke 130). However, Stein conceded and added two commas in exchange for a paintingâlater removing them, commenting âMina LoyâŠwas able to understand without the commas (130). In 1923, when Loy returned to Paris, she and Stein reunited. Loy wrote a two-part article and poem titled âGertrude Stein,â which was published in Transatlantic Review in 1924 (Burke 329). Her poem equates Stein to the âMadam Curie of language,â and was presented by Loy as a tribute to Stein at Natalie Barneyâs Paris salon in 1927.
A committed supporter of Philippe PĂ©tain, head of state of the pro-Nazi collaborationist Vichy regime in France during the Second World War, Steinâs activities and political views have been called into question. While seeming to be the embodiment of high modernism, as a Jewish, lesbian, woman writer, throughout her life Stein leaned to the political right. During WWII she was a propagandist for a Nazi-dominated political regime and a supporter of a ânew France.â Protected by her Nazi official friend, Bernard FaĂż, who acted to shield her and Toklas from persecution and her art collection from confiscation, Stein must have had some inherent fear for their safety. When urged to leave France by American embassy officials and friends, Stein declined stating, âit would be awfully uncomfortable and I am fussy about my foodâ (Will). Moreover, Stein endorsed Hitler for the 1934 Nobel Peace Prize, citing his ability to mobilize Germans and to remove âall elements of contest and struggle from Germany. By driving out the Jews and the democratic Left elementsâŠdriving out everything that conduces to activity. That means peaceâ (Greenhouse). Similarly, Stein was also seen performed the Nazi salute at Hitlerâs bunker in Berchtesgaden after the Allied victory in 1945 (Will).
Ironically, while identified with the modernist movements in art and literature, to Stein, the modern industrial revolution was a negative force on society, leading to its decline. For Stein, the âpath forward into the future often lays in a return to something lostâ (White). While Stein was pro-immigrant, pro-democratic, and anti-patriarchal, her last major work was poignantly the feminist libretto of the opera The Mother of Us All (1946). It tells the hopeful tale of Susan B. Anthony, leader of the suffragette movement and the social progression she and the cause represented. On July 27, 1946, Stein died before coming out of anesthesia after a stomach cancer operation. She is interred at the Pere Lachaise Cemetery in Paris, France. Toklas is buried next to her. Carl Van Vechten was named as her literary executor, and made sure more of her works were published after her death.
Works Cited
Burke, Carolyn. Becoming Modern: The Life of Mina Loy. University of California Press, 1997.
Galvin, Mary E. Queer Poetics: Five Modernist Women Writers. Greenwood Press, 1999.
Goody, Alex. Modernist Articulations: a Cultural Study of Djuna Barnes, Mina Loy, and
Gertrude Stein. Palgrave Macmillan, 2007.
Greenhouse, Emily. âWhy Won’t the Met Tell the Whole Truth About Gertrude Stein?â The New Yorker, The New Yorker, 19 June 2017, www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/why-wont-the-met-tell-the-whole-truth-about-gertrude-stein.
Loy, Mina, and Roger L. Conover. The Last Lunar Baedeker. The Jargon Society, Inc., 1982.
Kellner, Bruce. A Gertrude Stein Companion: Content with the Example. Greenwood, 1988.
Nelson, Cary. âA Century of Innovation: American Poetry from 1900 to the Present.â The Oxford Handbook of Modern and Contemporary American Poetry, Oxford Univ. Press, 2014, pp. 3â49.
Sprigge, Elizabeth. Gertrude Stein, Her Life and Work. Harper, 1957.
White, Edward. âThe Making of an American.â The Paris Review, 8 Apr. 2016, www.theparisreview.org/blog/2014/05/14/the-making-of-an-american/.
Will, Barbara. âThe Strange Politics of Gertrude Stein.â National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH), 2012, www.neh.gov/humanities/2012/marchapril/feature/the-strange-politics-gertrude-stein.
Other Biographies
![Alfred Kremyborg](/wp-content/uploads/cn3569_kreymborg1-349x349.jpg)
Alfred Kreymborg
![black and white portrait photograph of Alfred Stieglitz](/wp-content/uploads/330px-Alfred_Stieglitz-349x349.jpg)
Alfred Stieglitz
![AndrĂ© Breton](/wp-content/uploads/AndreÌ_Breton-1-349x349.jpg)
André Breton
![Arthur Cravan, Paris, circa 1910.](/wp-content/uploads/arthurcravan-349x349.jpg)
Arthur Cravan
![Baroness Elsa von Freytag-Loringhoven in costume](/wp-content/uploads/Baroness-Elsa-349x349.jpeg)
Baroness Elsa von Freytag-Loringhoven
![black and white photograph of Basil Bunting](/wp-content/uploads/basilbunting-349x349.jpg)
Basil Bunting
![black and white photograph of Marcel Duchamp, Francis Picabia, and Beatrice Wood taken at the Broadway Photo Shop in New York City c.1917](/wp-content/uploads/330px-Marcel_Duchamp_Francis_Picabia_and_Beatrice_Wood_at_the_Broadway_Photo_Shop_NYC_1917-349x349.jpg)
Beatrice Wood
![Walker Evans portrait of Berenice Abbott. Circa 1930.Credit Berenice Abbott Archive, Ryerson Image Center. Ronald Kurtz, administered by Commerce Graphics Ltd.](/wp-content/uploads/20150505-lens-abbott-2-blog480-349x349.jpg)
Berenice Abbott
![black and white portrait photograph of Carl Van Vechten](/wp-content/uploads/220px-Self-Portrait_of_Carl_Van_Vechten_Crisco_edit-349x349.jpg)
Carl Van Vechten
![Charles Henry Ford: writer, artist, and editor](/wp-content/uploads/044-charles-henry-ford-theredlist-349x349.jpg)
Charles Henri Ford
![black and white portrait photograph of Clara Tice with dog](/wp-content/uploads/lossless-page1-220px-ClaraTice1916.tif-349x349.png)
Clara Tice
![Constantin Brancusi](/wp-content/uploads/s-l300-349x349.jpg)
Constantin Brancusi
![Denise Levertov](/wp-content/uploads/D-Levertov-349x349.jpg)
Denise Levertov
![Djuna Barnes](/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Djunabarnes.jpg)
Djuna Barnes
![Dorothy Day c.1916](/wp-content/uploads/330px-Dorothy_Day_1916_cropped-349x349.jpg)
Dorothy Day
![black and white photograph of Elsa Schiaparelli c.1937](/wp-content/uploads/Elsa_schiaparelli_1937-349x349.jpg)
Elsa Schiaparelli
![black and white photograph of Eugene Jolas](/wp-content/uploads/eugenejolas-349x349.jpg)
Eugene Jolas
![Ezra Pound, ca. 1913.](/wp-content/uploads/Ezra-Pound-young-349x349.jpg)
Ezra Pound
![Fernand LĂ©ger, c. 1916](/wp-content/uploads/Fernand_LeÌger_c._1916-349x349.jpg)
Fernand LĂ©ger
![black and white portrait photograph of Filippo Tommaso Marinetti](/wp-content/uploads/Filippo_Tommaso_Marinetti-349x349.jpg)
Filipo Tomasso Marinetti
![black and white portrait photograph of Francis Simpson Stevens](/wp-content/uploads/stevens-349x349.jpg)
Frances Simpson Stevens
![Francis Picabia](/wp-content/uploads/F-Picabia-349x349.jpg)
Francis Picabia
![French art critic and writer of the dada movement](/wp-content/uploads/Gabriele_Buffet_Picabia-616x380-349x349.jpg)
Gabrielle Buffet-Picabia
![Foto giovanile di Papini nel decennio 1910-1920.](/wp-content/uploads/Papini2-349x349.jpg)
Giovanni Papini
![black and white photograph of Glenway Wescott](/wp-content/uploads/unnamed-349x349.png)
Glenway Wescott
![black and white photo of Hermine David](/wp-content/uploads/Photo_of_Hermine_David-349x349.jpg)
Hermine David
![Black and white portrait photograph of Isadora Duncan](/wp-content/uploads/Isadora_Duncan_portrait_cropped-349x349.jpg)
Isadora Duncan
![James Joyce](/wp-content/uploads/joycemodword-349x349.jpg)
James Joyce
![black and white photograph of Janet Flanner](/wp-content/uploads/flanner2-349x349.jpg)
Janet Flanner
![Black and white portrait photograph of Jean Cocteau c.1923](/wp-content/uploads/330px-Jean_Cocteau_b_Meurisse_1923-349x349.jpg)
Jean Cocteau
![Cornell in 1971](/wp-content/uploads/Joseph_Cornell_1971-349x349.jpg)
Joseph Cornell
![black and white photograph of Man Ray, Joseph Stella, and Marcel Duchamp c.1920](/wp-content/uploads/Man_Ray_1920_Three_Heads_Joseph_Stella_and_Marcel_Duchamp_gelatin_silver_print_20.7_x_15.7_cm_Museum_of_Modern_Art-349x349.jpg)
Joseph Stella
![Jules Pascin (1885 - 1930)](/wp-content/uploads/Jules_Pascin_image2017118171410-349x349.png)
Jules Pascin
![From the Harvard Art Museum Collection](/wp-content/uploads/Levy-349x349.jpg)
Julien Levy
![Katherine S. Dreier standing on stool with palette in from of mural at Saint Paul's School in New York](/wp-content/uploads/people-katherine-s-dreier-saint-pauls-school-mural-new-york-1905-349x349.jpg)
Katherine Sophie Dreier
![black and white photograph of Kathleen Fraser](/wp-content/uploads/fraser-hi-349x349.jpg)
Kathleen Fraser
![Black and white photograph of group of female war correspondents](/wp-content/uploads/War_correspondents-349x349.jpg)
Lee Miller
![black and white photograph of Luis Bunuel (Portoles)](/wp-content/uploads/Luis-BunÌuel-PortoleÌs-349x349.jpg)
Luis Buñuel (Portolés)
![Mabel Dodge Luhan wearing turban in yoga pose, circa 1915](/wp-content/uploads/573e3262e0243.image_-349x349.jpg)
Mabel Dodge
![Marcel Duchamp (With Pipe) - Photo by John D. Schiff](/wp-content/uploads/marcel-duchamp.jpgPortrait-349x349.jpg)
Marcel Duchamp
![Moore in her tricorn hat and cape](/wp-content/uploads/Marianne-Moore-2-349x349.jpg)
Marianne Craig Moore
![black and white portrait photograph of Mary Baker Eddy](/wp-content/uploads/Mary_Baker_Eddy-349x349.jpg)
Mary Baker Eddy
![The iconic portrait of Nancy Cunard, 1925, photographed by Man Ray © Man Ray Trust](/wp-content/uploads/nancy-cunard-349x349.jpg)
Nancy Cunard
![black and white portrait photograph of Natalie Barney](/wp-content/uploads/nataliebarney-349x349.jpg)
Natalie Barney
![black and white photograph of Neith Boyce](/wp-content/uploads/1013660-349x349.jpg)
Neith Boyce
![black and white photograph of Peggy Guggenheim](/wp-content/uploads/peggyguggenheim-349x349.jpg)
Peggy Guggenheim
![Richard Oelze](/wp-content/uploads/image1-2-349x349.jpg)
Richard Oelze
![Robert McAlmon, Image courtesy Clark Art Institute. clarkart.edu](/wp-content/uploads/mcalmon-349x349.jpg)
Robert McAlmon
![black and white photograph of Stephen Haweis c.1923](/wp-content/uploads/MBL_ALBUM-1-PAGE-38_478.web_-349x349.jpg)
Stephen Haweis
![At her bookshop, Shakespeare and Company](/wp-content/uploads/gettyimages-52128649-1024x1024-349x349.jpg)
Sylvia Beach
![Photo Credit: Alfred Eisenstaedt / LIFE](/wp-content/uploads/ts-eliot-349x349.jpg)
T.S. Eliot
![black and white photograph of Thelma Wood](/wp-content/uploads/T-Wood-349x349.jpg)
Thelma Wood
![Tristan Tzara: https://www.arthistoryarchive.com/arthistory/dada/Tristan-Tzara.html](/wp-content/uploads/Tristan-Tzara-07-349x349.gif)
Tristan Tzara
![black and white passport photograph of "Walter Arensberg"](/wp-content/uploads/image1-349x349.jpg)
Walter Conrad Arensberg
![William Carlos Williams passport photograph c.1921](/wp-content/uploads/330px-William_Carlos_Williams_passport_photograph_1921_cropped-349x349.jpg)